Today, CISA’s Office of Chemical Security updated a frequently asked question (FAQ) response on their Chemical Facility Anti-Terrorism Standards (CFATS) Knowledge Center. I also look at policy updates that should have been made. The FAQ Response revision updated the information provided to FAQ #1554 to reflect recent regulatory changes:
NOTE: The link provided for the FAQ in this post was copied from the CFATS Knowledge Center but may not work when followed from your machine. This is an artifact of that web site. If the links do not take you to the referenced FAQ, you will have to use the ‘Advanced Search’ function on the page to link to the FAQ or download the ‘All FAQs’ document at the bottom of the ‘Advanced Search’ page.
The revised information is an increase in the maximum civil penalty under 6 CFR 27.300(b)(3) from $38,139 to $41,093. This change was recently made when DHS updated their civil penalties to reflect inflation.
Down the Rabbit Hole – A Look at Static Policy Documents -
The FAQ response (both versions) refers readers to “Policy for Assessing a Civil Penalty under CFATS, policy number 02.08.03.010-1.0.” for additional information. The link is to the “CFATS Enforcement” web page under the “CFATS Laws and Regulations” web site. That page provides an overview of the enforcement options CISA has with respect to various violations of the CFATS regulations.
That page provides additional links to various CFATS program web pages. It also includes links to two pages specifically dealing with penalties:
The later is a policy document, dating back to 2017. This document needs to be updated. It still refers to “Department of Homeland Security’s Infrastructure Security Compliance Division (ISCD)” instead of the Office of Chemical Security. That is a relatively minor bureaucratic faux pax. The major problem is that the policy document still refers to the maximum daily penalty of $33,000 {para 2.3.1 on page 5}, that was the maximum penalty available in 2017. Due to annual inflation adjustment changes since that date, the figure is now the $41,093 referenced in the FAQ response.
Someone at CISA should consider if the recommended ‘fines’ listed for specific CFATS violations need to be adjusted to reflect the annual changes in the maximum daily penalty. I really suspect that CISA should be updating this policy document each year when the annual inflation adjustment final rule is published.